The ACC is voting for the proposal. Please refer to our communication thread for our rationale. https://gov.optimism.io/t/anticapture-commission-communication-thread/7501/
https://gov.optimism.io/t/upgrade-proposal-11-holocene-network-upgrade/9313/33
As one of the core development teams of Optimism Collective, we believe all the changes Holocene proposes are necessary: Derivation pipeline improvement, independent gas configurations, and more MIPS syscalls. The rollout plan is clear and was well executed in the test environments. We're voting for this proposal.
At SEEDGov, after reviewing the proposal, we believe it is ready for implementation.
https://gov.optimism.io/t/brichis-delegate-communication-thread/6353/29
All the proposed changes that are the chain derivation changes, the EIP-1559 elasticity parameter change and the MIPS related changes look reasonable and make sense, to be staged for the future major upgrades. The failure mode analysis provided for these changes is well-thought-out while these changes are not audited according to the Audit Framework.
Vote For. The changes to derivation are primarily focused at removing code that appears to be unnecessary based on experience, and simplifying the code base in this area. From a practical standpoint, this places more emphasis on the Sequencer to keep the chain running smoothly, but does not empower the Sequencer with anything it does not possess today. OP Labs has communicated that the Sequencer software already is capable of handling this increased burden. EIP-1559 allows for elastic gas limits, which scale costs towards a target. This was developed at the request of other OP stack operators, and we’re not sure we understand the argument that Optimism itself needs or wants this change, but will defer on this subject since it should not impact Optimism until/unless a future proposal changes the parameters for this. More generally, only one portion of this update was audited. This is consistent with the OP Labs Audit Framework, but is still not a best practice, and is a clear case of being pennywise and pound-foolish. We would support governance stepping in to provide audit subsidies to developers authoring network upgrades if OP Labs and OP Foundation feel they cannot afford to audit every upgrade by default.
Following DAB advice I'll vote for. I want to highlight the need for Audits on these things if possible.
This upgrade strengthens interoperability, block derivation, and gas configurability, aligning with the DAO’s objectives.
As a non-technical delegate, I am sitting this vote out and trust the judgement of the ACC and more technical members
We support this Holocene upgrade because it improves the OP Stack by making the system simpler, stricter, and better prepared for future features like Fault Proofs and Interoperability. The changes have been carefully tested and reviewed to ensure they are secure by the, with no expected downtime during the upgrade.
Supports Holocene upgrade for better efficiency, configurability, and compatibility, ensuring a robust Superchain ecosystem.
The frog croaks in agreement.
Loading more votes...